Interstellar Object 3I/Atlas Passed Mars Last Night

I was surprised to recently learn that NASA has aimed pretty much everything it has at 3I/Atlas, even the Perseverance Mars rover! <https://science.nasa.gov/solar-system/comets/3i-atlas/>

Have we gotten better at detecting these objects in the past 5 years or is the solar system going through a bumpy area of Milky Way lately? We have observed (or I have heard about) many interstellar objects in the past five years than any previous times.

Looking forward to seeing what images they received, especially after Avi Loeb's comments on it.

It is amazing how in under 100 years, we go from first object in space to controlling several spacecrafts in Mars orbit/surface in order to observe a specific object in the sky.

I like the fact that we have enough probes roaming around the solar system that we can redirect them to travel toward or at least look at an anomaly that seems worthy of study. It's not quite at the level of redirecting the Enterprise to study an anomaly but it's getting there.

the thought of this frozen rock drifting through space for billions of years fills me with existential dread :(

How likely is it that a random object from outside the solar system would pass so closely by Mars and Jupiter?

Why don't we have an interceptor ready to go for the next one?

> it’s traveling through our solar system at roughly 130,000 miles per hour (210,000 kph). That’s the highest velocity ever recorded for a solar system visitor.

so that's the fastest (macro & reachable) thing ever - good luck sticking a flag on it

https://science.nasa.gov/solar-system/comets/3i-atlas/ interesting blurb at the top of the site... "Due to the lapse in federal government funding, NASA is not updating this website."

"Oh, my God! That's the intergalactic mail van from Xenorph 44! We won't get any more supplies for another century!888----<((( Gaaah! Nothing to eat but Earthlings...."

- overheard on Avi Loeb's radio telescope, but fortunately mis-translated.

Was it glowing green?

> 3I/ATLAS is thought to have been drifting through interstellar space for many billions of years before encountering our solar system.

It is hard to believe, but it means it’s been a fiery comet for billions of years, how is that possible that it havent burned up…

I was surprised to recently learn that NASA has aimed pretty much everything it has at 3I/Atlas, even the Perseverance Mars rover! <https://science.nasa.gov/solar-system/comets/3i-atlas/>

Genuinely curious: what could the Mars rover possibly capture about this object that other instruments cannot? Is it our highest resolution imagery in the vicinity of Mars?

Not much, but just confirmation that it's in the expected part of the sky is quite exciting. There's a probable capture of it from Perseverance here (it's just a tiny faint smudge):

https://bsky.app/profile/stim3on.bsky.social/post/3m2aqnbwlw...

When you look at images of the comet Siding Spring made from Mars surface and orbit, it’s clear that neither of the instruments are really well suited for that type of observation. In such case, you just use everything you have and hope for the best.

I supposed that depends on if the object deploys a probe to go take a selfie with the rover? Would be a damn shame to miss capturing evidence of it up close and personal...

my favourite sci-fi idea about this is that the aliens know we love shiny things so they give us a comet to look at while they have their annual picnic somewhere nearby.

It is amazing how in under 100 years, we go from first object in space to controlling several spacecrafts in Mars orbit/surface in order to observe a specific object in the sky.

> it’s traveling through our solar system at roughly 130,000 miles per hour (210,000 kph). That’s the highest velocity ever recorded for a solar system visitor.

so that's the fastest (macro & reachable) thing ever - good luck sticking a flag on it

There has been a significant increase in NEO observation projects in the last eight years and there’s one coming online soon that should increase the detection capabilities even more.

Pan-STARRS (discovered 1I/ʻOumuamua), Zwicky Transient Facility (2I/Borisov), and ATLAS (3I/ATLAS) are the major existing projects and the Rubin Observatory/LSST will be a huge upgrade. We’re going to detect a lot more if these objects, especially since a lot of the work of the projects are looking at historical data.

Computing Power has increased tremendously, along with the higher resolution of digital imaging technology compared to analog film plates. Sky Survey projects like the Vera C. Rubin Observatory have become active in recent years, which generate Terabytes of spectrographic data each night which can be rapidly examined for differences from previous captures. In the past each exposure had to be hand-aligned on a Light table and “flipped” between to spot differences.

From wikipedia: "As of 2025, three interstellar objects have been discovered traveling through the Solar System: 1I/ʻOumuamua in 2017, 2I/Borisov in 2019, and 3I/ATLAS in 2025"

I would guess that observation improves over time. The wikipedia article is fascinating, estimating 10,000 such objects passing within Neptune's orbit in our solar system each day. I think that includes dust and sand sized objects.

It's detection, not a particularly crowded area of space. These rocks are hard to see, and one needs at least 3 observations (in theory, but in practice more) to compute their path and determine that they're extrasolar. Within 5 years we'll probably be detecting several of them a week.

5 years ago space got a whole force dedicated to it in the US. Perhaps this is the result of an increase in military research efforts? The timing is an interesting coincidence if anything.

the thought of this frozen rock drifting through space for billions of years fills me with existential dread :(

Astronomy usually has that kind of "Lovecraftian" sense of cosmic insignificance when you put things to sacale. Also, being alone at 3am in the middle of nowhere, cold and kind of sleepy, looking at a gas cloud lightyears away, adds to it. But it is also fascinating.

Quite the opposite for me. I’m fascinated and inspired by the fact that this rock escaped the gravity well of one star and is now visiting another.

Now think about how "lucky" this one is it got to float through a solar system.

80 years (if lucky) is an unfathomably cruel prank and a prison.

Wait until you hear what Earth has been up to in that same time.

Why don't we have an interceptor ready to go for the next one?

How likely is it that a random object from outside the solar system would pass so closely by Mars and Jupiter?

Looking forward to seeing what images they received, especially after Avi Loeb's comments on it.

Was it glowing green?

"Oh, my God! That's the intergalactic mail van from Xenorph 44! We won't get any more supplies for another century!888----<((( Gaaah! Nothing to eat but Earthlings...."

- overheard on Avi Loeb's radio telescope, but fortunately mis-translated.

Trip to Mars (~its closest point) is much longer than time we had. The chances the next one will be close enough to Earth and low enough speed so it can be matched is astronomically low and such interceptor would be quite expensive

I may be super naive here, but are we really defining "close" or is it that the object is close enough that it makes sense to point our objects that are close to Jupiter at the new object?

It is passing between two point in our night sky. I believe from a plane view, if you look at our universe from the perspective of it laying flat, it is my understanding the spin of our universe means that everything ends up within a flat plane, so in a 3 dimensional space, we have a limited Y axis. The other planets are spaced out across the X and Y axis, this is passing between or across two points.

Am I thinking of this right? I know very little about astronomy.

I wonder if we are going through a debris cloud and these are just the first small objects.

How likely is it that a random alien object does a wellness check on a barren planet in the same decade the humans happen to turn on the big survey telescope array?

Any object not doing so is very unlikely to be seen by us.

zero. It must be the Borg after the time jump.

Avi’s the new “it’s Aliens” meme guy

I had dinner with one of the co-authors Wednesday night. He's doubling down on the "significance" test that has H0 that all possible incoming trajectories are equally likely.

He's convinced it's an essentially a local phenomenon. I look forward to how he spins this paper.

Here's an interview of his on this

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nf0xB3EtQX0

https://science.nasa.gov/solar-system/comets/3i-atlas/ interesting blurb at the top of the site... "Due to the lapse in federal government funding, NASA is not updating this website."

at least it's not saying "thanks to the radical left democrats" like other govt websites

> 3I/ATLAS is thought to have been drifting through interstellar space for many billions of years before encountering our solar system.

It is hard to believe, but it means it’s been a fiery comet for billions of years, how is that possible that it havent burned up…

Well nothing much in hard vacuum is "fiery" - comets in our solar system do get ablated by the solar wind as they orbit the sun more closely; I assume in this case the majority of those billions of years were in deep space where there wasn't much pushing/pulling mass off.

Because what makes it glow is actually solar wind from our sun as it passes through the solar system.

For possibly billions of years, it has simply been an inert lump of ice passing through the universe.

If it were traveling through interstellar space, it would have been highly irradiated but it would also have been far from any source of heat. From what we know of it so far, it has some strange chemistry going on, but that’s somewhat expected given its estimated age. We’d also need to assume that a few billion years of interstellar radiation would do strange things we haven’t really seen before hence pointing every instrument possible at it.

Comets don’t do anything much until they get close to a star.

I supposed that depends on if the object deploys a probe to go take a selfie with the rover? Would be a damn shame to miss capturing evidence of it up close and personal...

my favourite sci-fi idea about this is that the aliens know we love shiny things so they give us a comet to look at while they have their annual picnic somewhere nearby.

Not much, but just confirmation that it's in the expected part of the sky is quite exciting. There's a probable capture of it from Perseverance here (it's just a tiny faint smudge):

https://bsky.app/profile/stim3on.bsky.social/post/3m2aqnbwlw...

> just confirmation that it's in the expected part of the sky is quite exciting

It would be funny if it behaves "as expected" when in the range of our instruments, but not when it thinks we can't see it :)

A flyby is fine, and I'm willing to explore some 1960's propulsion solutions.

I wonder if we are going through a debris cloud and these are just the first small objects.

We have only recently been able to detect them at scale, so we should not confuse first ones detected with first ones to arrive in the solar system. It’s just as likely they are the tail end of a debris cloud, but our detection tech wasn’t up to spotting all the previous ones.

I find this to be an interesting thought.

This one is anything but small.

I may be super naive here, but are we really defining "close" or is it that the object is close enough that it makes sense to point our objects that are close to Jupiter at the new object?

Am I thinking of this right? I know very little about astronomy.

There’s no evidence that the universe is spinning. The observable universe is not a flat plane - we see galaxies in all directions and at all distances.

You may be thinking of our galaxy (the Milky Way) or even our solar system, which both rotate and as such are both somewhat flattened (the solar system much more so than the galaxy.)

But what’s happening here has little to do with that. If you imagine the closest distance that Earth gets to Mars as a yardstick, 3I/Atlas is about half that yardstick’s distance from Mars right now - much closer than Earth ever gets. It’s practically in Mars’ back yard.

From wikipedia: "As of 2025, three interstellar objects have been discovered traveling through the Solar System: 1I/ʻOumuamua in 2017, 2I/Borisov in 2019, and 3I/ATLAS in 2025"

Quite the opposite for me. I’m fascinated and inspired by the fact that this rock escaped the gravity well of one star and is now visiting another.

Now think about how "lucky" this one is it got to float through a solar system.

There has been a significant increase in NEO observation projects in the last eight years and there’s one coming online soon that should increase the detection capabilities even more.

2I/Borisov was not discovered by Zwicky Transient Facility .

The comet was discovered on 30 August 2019 by amateur astronomer Gennadiy Borisov at his personal observatory MARGO in Nauchnij, Crimea, using a 0.65 meter telescope he designed and built himself.

honestly the times I was on a proper telescope, I was shitting myself making sure I made the most of the time going down my list of targets and not getting something wrong and pointing at the wrong star or getting the wrong setting. that and the daemon that had to be restarted every half an hour or so because it crashed. I did not have the energy or time for philosophy. I guess that's the difference between the phd student and the professor haha!

5 years ago space got a whole force dedicated to it in the US. Perhaps this is the result of an increase in military research efforts? The timing is an interesting coincidence if anything.

We know exactly who discovered these objects, what tech they were using, and where the funding came from, and it wasn’t from space force.

80 years (if lucky) is an unfathomably cruel prank and a prison.

I'm quite hopeful that anyone under 40 (arbitrary, mostly because I'm in my mid-30s) will get to LEV (longevity escape velocity) - there's a ton of anti-ageing and disease-curing research going on, especially now with the likes of DeepMind and others accelerating said research.

That's assuming you manage to avoid death from microplastics, climate change or AI-related societal collapse, etc.

It’s worth noting that we went from wondering if other stars had planets to hitting 6000 detected so far in about four decades with just 33 years since the first discovery of an exoplanet (and 30 years since one was found orbiting a main-sequence star—that first was actually two planets which orbited a neutron star).

Wait until you hear what Earth has been up to in that same time.

Comets don’t do anything much until they get close to a star.

zero. It must be the Borg after the time jump.

I had dinner with one of the co-authors Wednesday night. He's doubling down on the "significance" test that has H0 that all possible incoming trajectories are equally likely.

He's convinced it's an essentially a local phenomenon. I look forward to how he spins this paper.

Here's an interview of his on this

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nf0xB3EtQX0

A flyby is fine, and I'm willing to explore some 1960's propulsion solutions.

This one is anything but small.

Because what makes it glow is actually solar wind from our sun as it passes through the solar system.

For possibly billions of years, it has simply been an inert lump of ice passing through the universe.

It could be extra-galactic. It's going at a fair clip, and (if I haven't dropped a zero or ten) it would only take around 800 million years to get here from one of the Magellanic Clouds.

Just as an indicator of the speed and possible distances.

Yeah but then it wouldn’t be drifting would it?

Joke explanation: a drifting vehicle is burning tires and leaving a cloud of smoke behind, like a comet.

Wind in a vacuum, that's interesting.

at least it's not saying "thanks to the radical left democrats" like other govt websites

Some departments have even added similar language to employees' e-mail out-of-office messages.

Looks like you were downvoted by someone who either thought you were kidding, thought you were posting false partisan flamebait, or thinks that the language used by the Trump administration is just peachy keen. Regardless, they were wrong.

https://abc7.com/post/government-websites-displaying-message...

So far left, they are actually far right

Any object not doing so is very unlikely to be seen by us.

How likely is it that a random alien object does a wellness check on a barren planet in the same decade the humans happen to turn on the big survey telescope array?

Avi’s the new “it’s Aliens” meme guy

There’s no evidence that the universe is spinning. The observable universe is not a flat plane - we see galaxies in all directions and at all distances.

You may be thinking of our galaxy (the Milky Way) or even our solar system, which both rotate and as such are both somewhat flattened (the solar system much more so than the galaxy.)

I find this to be an interesting thought.

Shuffle a deck of cards, and statistically no one has ever shuffled the same sequence in all of human history.

It is extraordinarily unlikely you will shuffle one particular order of cards. It is 100% likely you will result in a sequence of cards.

Space is full of trillions and trillions and trillions of these. Given the rate of detection, we’ll probably see them come through regularly.

Aliens have been doing this every few years for 250,000 years but we've just only managed to build barely decent telescopes ;)

Pretty likely if there are a lot of them!

No, he's the new "we should consider what this would look like if it were an artifact of an alien civilization" guy. You know, open minded.

He's also a well respected and very accomplished person who has acknowledged this is a comet.

If it happens to slow down and change trajectory after it passes behind the sun, he might change his tune but he's pretty focused on the science at this point.

> There’s no evidence that the universe is spinning.

True, but if it were that would solve some problems in observations:

https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article/538/4/3038/8090496?lo...

Thanks for clarifying that. And you're right, I was referring to our solar system, not the universe.

It's in Mars' backyard, but was it, or will it also be in Jupiter's backyard? I couldn't understand that from the original post.

It seemed to me that it was just that our telescopes/cameras near Jupiter would be pointed in that direction.

Earth is currently traveling through the Local Interstellar Cloud, a region of gas, dust, and plasma, and a recent study suggests that the solar system may have recently passed through a dense cloud of supernova debris. Evidence for this supernova event includes the presence of the radioactive isotope iron-60.

2I/Borisov was not discovered by Zwicky Transient Facility .

The comet was discovered on 30 August 2019 by amateur astronomer Gennadiy Borisov at his personal observatory MARGO in Nauchnij, Crimea, using a 0.65 meter telescope he designed and built himself.

That’s interesting. If it was possible to do on a homemade telescope, then why were no interstellar objects discovered before 1A?

> just confirmation that it's in the expected part of the sky is quite exciting

It would be funny if it behaves "as expected" when in the range of our instruments, but not when it thinks we can't see it :)

Every confirmation is a data point.

We know exactly who discovered these objects, what tech they were using, and where the funding came from, and it wasn’t from space force.

"we" does not include me, which is why I posed it as a question, and made the allowance that it's at least an interesting coincidence to me.

I'm not sure why that warrants a flood of downvotes, especially increasing after your message called me out, but hey I guess that's HN now.

That's assuming you manage to avoid death from microplastics, climate change or AI-related societal collapse, etc.

In your perspective, why would these drugs be made available to the general public given they'd be arguably the most valuable thing every produced in human history? Presumably one or a few companies would own the IP, so they would of course charge massive sums for them because that's what corporations are supposed to do. So how does that not happen?

A funny overview of the recent history https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gai8dMA19Sw

Wind in a vacuum, that's interesting.

So far left, they are actually far right

> There’s no evidence that the universe is spinning.

True, but if it were that would solve some problems in observations:

https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article/538/4/3038/8090496?lo...

Aliens have been doing this every few years for 250,000 years but we've just only managed to build barely decent telescopes ;)

Every confirmation is a data point.

https://abc7.com/post/government-websites-displaying-message...

It could be extra-galactic. It's going at a fair clip, and (if I haven't dropped a zero or ten) it would only take around 800 million years to get here from one of the Magellanic Clouds.

Just as an indicator of the speed and possible distances.

> “But based on the researchers’ analyses of the interstellar object’s vertical motion in the galaxy (its path is known to weave up and down in the galactic disk), they concluded that it likely originated from the Milky Way’s thin disk, not its thick disk as was mentioned some months ago. The thin disk contains somewhat younger objects than the thick disk.”

Yeah but then it wouldn’t be drifting would it?

Joke explanation: a drifting vehicle is burning tires and leaving a cloud of smoke behind, like a comet.

Whether it's drifting through space or hammering through at dozens of kilometres a second is rather a matter of perspective. Perhaps as far as it's concerned, its sedate drift has been interrupted by a very ill-mannered solar system making a reckless close pass.

Some departments have even added similar language to employees' e-mail out-of-office messages.

Thats correct. Some groups have. More groups refuse to break the Hatch Act and take partisan sides.

Theres a LOT of people who work for the government that want to do a good job, and faithfully keep doing what they're paid to do. Administrations dont matter. The mission does. And that mission goes year by year.

Well, until now.

There is a lot of darkness, and we can only look in so many places. We tend to look along the plane of our elliptic because that is where everything in our solar system is. Looking elsewhere is possible, but increasingly lonely/low odds.

Thanks for clarifying that. And you're right, I was referring to our solar system, not the universe.

It's in Mars' backyard, but was it, or will it also be in Jupiter's backyard? I couldn't understand that from the original post.

It seemed to me that it was just that our telescopes/cameras near Jupiter would be pointed in that direction.

Pretty likely if there are a lot of them!

Shuffle a deck of cards, and statistically no one has ever shuffled the same sequence in all of human history.

It is extraordinarily unlikely you will shuffle one particular order of cards. It is 100% likely you will result in a sequence of cards.

Space is full of trillions and trillions and trillions of these. Given the rate of detection, we’ll probably see them come through regularly.

No, he's the new "we should consider what this would look like if it were an artifact of an alien civilization" guy. You know, open minded.

He's also a well respected and very accomplished person who has acknowledged this is a comet.

If it happens to slow down and change trajectory after it passes behind the sun, he might change his tune but he's pretty focused on the science at this point.

A funny overview of the recent history https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gai8dMA19Sw

"we" does not include me, which is why I posed it as a question, and made the allowance that it's at least an interesting coincidence to me.

I'm not sure why that warrants a flood of downvotes, especially increasing after your message called me out, but hey I guess that's HN now.

That’s interesting. If it was possible to do on a homemade telescope, then why were no interstellar objects discovered before 1A?

It's Juice (Jupiter Icy Moons Explorer) and it's not yet anywhere near Jupiter. Its trajectory has a few slingshot loops around Venus and Earth, and it's just coming off the Venus encounter.

It's about 0.43 AU from the comet at its nearest, whereas Earth will be pretty much on the opposite side of the Sun, making observations difficult from here.

Edit: Earth, Mars and Jupiter are in roughly 120 degrees from each other as seen from the Sun, with the Earth-Sun-Jupiter angle closing up fast and the E-S-M angle growing slightly slower. In about two months the E-S-M angle will be 180.

Then I guess we'll see another one soon (unless we freak them out by noticing them and broadcasting about it!).

Once more survey telescopes like Nancy Grace Roman and Xuntian come online we'll increasingly find out how many there really are and I suppose if they seem to like buzzing the proverbial tower.

That's my point. If you turn on several telescopes particularly good at seeing these things and see three objects in fairly quick succession, the implication is probably (not certainly) that there are lots of interstellar objects hammering in all the time, not that the first ones you see are particularly special, even if one of them seems to be making a statistically unlikely near approach to Mars.

He was well respected. As the saying goes, open your mind too far and it falls out of the cranium.

Last I checked, he was making claims well beyond that.

Well, you know what they say; don't be so open-minded that your brain falls out.

I am open minded, but Arthur Clarke solved it. If it was alien it would have slingshotted around the sun. Unless it is on collision course with a planet or using the sun to modify its course towards another star - you can assume that it is not alien and functioning.

His Galileo Project is explicitly looking for “extraterrestrial technological signatures”, and he’s just using any opportunity for hype about that.

He got attention for writing about this for Oumuamua, and now he’s just rinsing and repeating for 3I/Atlas. It’s exactly like any youtuber chasing the most effective clickbait.

It’s like when Altman talks about AIs building a Dyson sphere. Everyone with any understanding of the issues knows it’s self-serving hype.

Somewhere in the galaxy, silicon-based lifeforms who enjoy swimming in molten lead have trained their telescopes on our solar system and mapped it. They have assumed all the planets here are incapable of supporting life, except for the second one: It's right in their habitable zone. Their ships are speeding toward Venus as we speak.

FWIW, HN values directness and precision, even in questions. I bet if you'd said "Did increased military spending have anything to do with this?" you'd get a quick answer "no" and few downvotes; but what you actually said was "Perhaps this is the result of an increase in military research efforts" with a question mark on the end, and I expect HN was reacting to that.

Your original question is indistinguishable from a societal suicide cultist "just asking questions" to promote dear leader. There's an endless flood of that, so the best thing to do is downvote (or flag) and move on. Engaging just drives further engagement.

The hard part isn't having a telescope, but analyzing the images for objects that have moved between successive observations. Digital astrophotography and analysis software have been getting steadily cheaper and better, which leads to more amateur comet hunters each watching more sky, which has rapidly improved the odds of catching rare objects.

I'm not sure how the progress of institutional and amateur observations compare. Obviously the big guys benefit from the same technological advancement, but I don't know whether the fraction of new objects discovered by amateurs has been growing or not. I suspect the odds of the first interstellar object being found by an amateur were still pretty long.

I don’t know if that applies to the sky surveys.

Thats correct. Some groups have. More groups refuse to break the Hatch Act and take partisan sides.

Well, until now.

Good lord. That's worse than I'd heard.

We're pretty much hosed.

Yes, the solar system is moving (rotating) relative to the galactic core at 230 KM/s, far faster than this object is moving relative to us.

Depending on its origin/history, it’s getting run over by a runaway train, or taking a sedate walk.

Hopefully our solar system isn't making a reckless pass into the path of the fragments from a historic explosion and we're just seeing the first few.

> Theres a LOT of people who work for the government that want to do a good job, and faithfully keep doing what they're paid to do.

And the current administration calls those people “the deep state” and wants to get rid of them.

It's Juice (Jupiter Icy Moons Explorer) and it's not yet anywhere near Jupiter. Its trajectory has a few slingshot loops around Venus and Earth, and it's just coming off the Venus encounter.

It's about 0.43 AU from the comet at its nearest, whereas Earth will be pretty much on the opposite side of the Sun, making observations difficult from here.

His Galileo Project is explicitly looking for “extraterrestrial technological signatures”, and he’s just using any opportunity for hype about that.

He got attention for writing about this for Oumuamua, and now he’s just rinsing and repeating for 3I/Atlas. It’s exactly like any youtuber chasing the most effective clickbait.

It’s like when Altman talks about AIs building a Dyson sphere. Everyone with any understanding of the issues knows it’s self-serving hype.

Fwiw, Avi's hypothesis for Oumuamua was not that it was functioning, but that it was old, defunct light sail.

If _some_ kind of life is possible in Venus, shouldn't Venus have it?

That's how life works on Earth. If it _can_ live somewhere, it's probably already there. We think that's related to how it can survive and adapt, so it's reasonable to assume other life would be similar in that regard.

Therefore, by this logic, if Venus is able to sustain any life, it should already be there.

I know it sounds weird. What if life never got there? Well, it had plenty of opportunity. The universe is old and lots of things happened in it already.

Maybe life is a late addition to the universe, and we're one of the first instances of it. Or maybe it's rare, and we're lucky. Both the "life is new" and "life is rare" ideas, however, paint a picture of Earth being a special case somehow. "We are a special case" is not a very satisfying answer though (from the scientific point of view).

He was well respected. As the saying goes, open your mind too far and it falls out of the cranium.

I think 3I/Atlas is a comet.

But I also think the question "what if it wasn't" is useful to consider.

I'd label anyone unwilling to discuss that topic a crank, not the other way round.

There's an excellent quote from the WH40k universe:

    An open mind is like a fortress with its gates unbarred and its walls unguarded.

Um, ok. I think he's still doing ok and his fellow academics would prefer he didn't openly speculate about pet theories. They think it is embarrassing.

But ask yourself where we'd be if noone ever asked what if.

There's a reason he called his project to observe anomalous phenomenon The Galileo Project. Ring a bell?

Then I guess we'll see another one soon (unless we freak them out by noticing them and broadcasting about it!).

Once more survey telescopes like Nancy Grace Roman and Xuntian come online we'll increasingly find out how many there really are and I suppose if they seem to like buzzing the proverbial tower.

Last I checked, he was making claims well beyond that.

Well, you know what they say; don't be so open-minded that your brain falls out.

Good lord. That's worse than I'd heard.

We're pretty much hosed.

Hopefully our solar system isn't making a reckless pass into the path of the fragments from a historic explosion and we're just seeing the first few.

> Theres a LOT of people who work for the government that want to do a good job, and faithfully keep doing what they're paid to do.

And the current administration calls those people “the deep state” and wants to get rid of them.

In fact, we already have; that's why there's a 3 in its name.

Yeah, like exoplanets. When I was in middle school there were none. Now there’s 6,000 confirmed ones.

I’m curious how unlikely it is. Seems very, very unlikely to pass by 2 major planets.

"What if 3I/Atlas is responsible for the Wow! Signal?!" is one of the sillier ones

He's definitely turned into a "I'm just asking questions and keeping an open mind" kinda grifter, whatever his past qualifications and respectability

Nonsense. Open minded means not precluding possibilities based on irrational bias, which would only increases intelligence.

I don’t know if that applies to the sky surveys.

1) they are new 2) they are still limited in coverage area (https://irsa.ipac.caltech.edu/applications/FinderChart/docs/...)

Yes, the solar system is moving (rotating) relative to the galactic core at 230 KM/s, far faster than this object is moving relative to us.

Depending on its origin/history, it’s getting run over by a runaway train, or taking a sedate walk.

Tangentially, I enjoy reminding my kids how long it takes our star to complete a rotation around the Milky Way, and then also point out that we can go to a museum and see fossils of what life looked like one galactic rotation ago. It gives the right amount of backward and forward perspective about the rock we live on that I want them to keep tucked away in the corner of their mind.

This object is "moving" at roughly 58 km/s. It's doing a leisurely Sunday drive and getting overtaken by someone 3x their speed.

Fwiw, Avi's hypothesis for Oumuamua was not that it was functioning, but that it was old, defunct light sail.

Um, ok. I think he's still doing ok and his fellow academics would prefer he didn't openly speculate about pet theories. They think it is embarrassing.

But ask yourself where we'd be if noone ever asked what if.

There's a reason he called his project to observe anomalous phenomenon The Galileo Project. Ring a bell?