"It is characteristic of such knowledge [ethics] that it should be deficient in “exactness,” in precision of statement, and closeness of logical concatenation. We must not look for a mathematics of conduct. The subject-matter of Human Conduct is not governed by necessary and uniform laws. But this does not mean that it is subject to no laws."
"[T]he man of education will seek exactness so far in each subject as the nature of the thing admits, it being plainly much the same absurdity to put up with a mathematician who tries to persuade instead of proving, and to demand strict demonstrative reasoning of a Rhetorician."
Aristotle never said this. It's Will Durant.
https://medium.com/the-mission/my-favourite-quote-of-all-tim...
https://old.reddit.com/r/askphilosophy/comments/s2n3s/source...
This invalidates the post for me, it takes it from academic research to fanboy posting.
The aim of the wise is not to secure pleasure, but to avoid pain.
Reminds me of Charlie Munger's Inversion principle that he borrowed from German mathematician Carl Gustav Jacob Jacobi's man muss immer umkehren. https://fs.blog/inversion/ We are what we repeatedly do. Excellence, then, is not an act, but a habit.
As counter points, read Cedirc Chin's Problems with deliberate practice, https://commoncog.com/the-problems-with-deliberate-practice/ and Sensemaking as the heart of expertise, https://commoncog.com/sensemaking-heart-of-expertise/ It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it.
This Amjad Masad comment lives rent-free in my head: "Tolerating some amount of cognitive dissonance is one of the best things that I was able to develop in myself ... people don't update their beliefs when new evidence comes to light ... The drive to avoid cognitive dissonance shackles you to your existing beliefs (see confirmation bias)". https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11799477 (2016).cf. Why people that are often right change their minds often, https://fs.blog/some-advice-from-jeff-bezos/
he's quiet possibly referring to happiness as a relationship (with family, friends, colleagues, citizens etc) rather than just by oneself / isolation / individual. he famously said "man by nature is a political animal" (or social if you prefer)
Edit:
Between the misattributions, fabricated quotes, listicle format, thin explanatory paragraphs, and use of “delve” (posted Nov 2024 - during ChatGPT’s Delve Era), this is a pretty embarrassing thing for a Liberal Arts college to post.
My favorite part is the useless comment bellow each quote like: "The commenter above has stated that the quote is not from aristotle, this is important for the article"
https://archive.org/details/religionpursuito0000lowe/page/n5...
Entertaining an idea is understanding it. And, there is some research to show that understanding an idea is believing it. Hence, understanding an idea and not believing it is very effortful.
[1] https://bear.warrington.ufl.edu/brenner/mar7588/Papers/gilbe...
Philosophy is not about clever observations! They are developing systems and arguments you have to actually read to understand.
Along the same lines: "Education is the ability to listen to almost anything without losing your temper or your self-confidence." -- Robert Frost
apparently not, actually:
"The earliest that this quotation appears in print is in Religion and the Pursuit of Truth (1959) by Lowell Bennion."
or
"First attributed to Aristotle in Lowell L. Bennion, Religion and the Pursuit of Truth (1959). Unfound as such.
Sometimes thought (though I feel it's a bit of a stretch) a misinterpretation of Nicomachean Ethics 1.3.4 (1094b): "For it is the mark of an educated person to search for the same kind of clarity in each topic to the extent that the nature of the matter accepts it.""
What a cool way to convey the benefits of having strong friendships.
https://sourcelibrary.org/book/chuang-tzu-mystic-moralist-an...
On Marcus Aurelius: he's often recommended mindlessly (especially in tech circles). I actually to suggest to read him last. He does have valuable things to say, but he's the most depressive of the Big Three Stoics. You can better appreciate Aurelius if you've already digested some Socratic dialogues and Epictetus. One of the top-most Stoicism scholars (A. A. Long) describes Marcus Aurelius this way: "a melancholy emperor, who was hardly a card-carrying Stoic".
FWIW, here's[1] my recommended reading order and top English translations from five years ago. Cut out the cheap rehashes by people such as Ryan Holiday and stick to the originals. A bonus note[2] on the Roman gem, Cicero, from six years ago.
The first section is simple but profound: all beings strive for the good for themselves, so we have a starting point to address the good of each and possibly all even across fundamental differences.
> he has some pretty messed up and weird views
They do, but by insisting on rationalizing any view rather than leaving it as a religious given, he sets the stage for destroying bias. Remember, Aristotle trained Alexander, and Alexander's military was successful because they embraced rather than destroying the people conquered (if they didn't fight back), and they even lost a fair bit of his Greek ways.
I agree it’s still interesting that major religions were not founded at the time of the early philosophers — maybe it’s because religion as we conceive of it today depends on a type of bureaucracy that wasn’t achievable in the classical era?
Would love to know if others have takes.
In his defense (sorry if defending him offends here), women probably did, at the time, often have fewer teeth due to worse dental care.
edit: whoa, I didn't realize how racist this guy was. He could be classified as a eugenicist I suppose.
He also believed in spontaneous generation (fair, without technology we have now it would be really confusing to understand where all kinds of things come from).
Seemed to believe infinity was impossible yet also that the heavens are infinite. Maybe he distinguished between the earthly and heavenly planes, but still seemed to think they were similarly constructed from elements.
The list goes on.
These are unfortunately still all too common beliefs. The latter has mostly been folded into racial essentialism and racial realist beliefs, because slavery is no longer legal (13th amendment loophole notwithstanding) and you can still find people arguing women are intellectually inferior and incapable of rational thought.
The whole anti-DEI movement is based on the premise that non-whites and women categorically don't deserve the same status in the workforce as white men, and the only reason they have "equality" is due to anti-white racism.
An original source for this. I wonder if wisdom teeth affected this count? It’s so odd of a claim
Aristotle has flaws, that's all.
I love his work on happiness. On the academic side of Philosophy, I believe his conception stands alongside what is typically called "Hedonism" defining the two major schools of thought, obviously with modern takes and twists. See the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy on "Happiness" if you're interested.
Also, he was referring to people performing labour, not people adhering to spiritual belief or ideological systems.
I see what you mean, but I don't think this means what he believed was true. I see it as categorically different. People adhering to beliefs without critical thought vs being forced into labour due to their 'nature' are very different matters.
many people are meant to be slaves is also a fact -- it is not like everyone is gifted cerebrally, or even blessed to be in an environment where, by the time they are adults, have been shown a good formula for life; so consequently a section of the society is destined to be just slaves, it just needs the presence of a manipulator.
Aristotle, being an endless questioning guy he was, might have figured this out, although i'm not sure.
I think you're committing a naturalistic fallacy, and I don't agree at all that people are ever meant to be slaves.
The most I can agree to is that "some humans are born into slavery due to chance". This is factual. That people are meant to be slaves is not a fact. Perhaps we have a language barrier here.
I've no disagreements with your position or moral principles. But spherical cow is different from reality.
Image: Line engraving by P. Fidanza after Raphael Sanzio.
Aristotle, one of the most influential philosophers of ancient Greece, laid foundational ideas in ethics, logic, politics, and natural sciences that continue to shape our understanding of the world today. A student of Plato and tutor to Alexander the Great, Aristotle established his own school, the Lyceum, where he explored diverse topics, from biology to metaphysics. His work continues to be a source of timeless wisdom, especially in the realms of virtue, knowledge, and happiness.
In this post, we’ve compiled 25 of Aristotle’s most profound quotes, each accompanied by insights to help understand his teachings. These quotes, primarily from his works Nicomachean Ethics and Metaphysics, reveal his approach to living a fulfilled and virtuous life.
This statement emphasises the role of habits in shaping character, suggesting that consistent virtuous actions lead to excellence, making it a part of one’s nature. Delve into Aristotle’s exploration of ethics in Nicomachean Ethics, where he elaborates on virtues, moral character, and the pursuit of a flourishing life.
Aristotle believed happiness (eudaimonia) is achieved through a life of virtuous actions and self-improvement, emphasising personal responsibility in attaining happiness. Learn more about Aristotle’s view of happiness as a life-long pursuit in Nicomachean Ethics.
For Aristotle, true education nurtures both intellectual and moral virtues, shaping not just one’s intellect but character. Aristotle explores this balance in Politics and Nicomachean Ethics.
Self-awareness is central to Aristotle’s philosophy, as understanding one’s character is the foundation for moral development. He addresses self-knowledge as a vital aspect of the good life in Nicomachean Ethics.
Aristotle saw courage as essential to virtue, arguing that facing fears leads to freedom from emotional constraints. Explore his views on courage as a moral virtue in Nicomachean Ethics.
Aristotle regarded friendship as one of the highest goods, rooted in mutual respect and shared virtues. For his complete discourse on friendship, see Nicomachean Ethics, Book VIII.
Aristotle emphasised the importance of early moral education, believing virtues developed in youth lead to lifelong character. This is a recurring theme in Nicomachean Ethics.
True wisdom, Aristotle believed, involves seeking a life free from unnecessary pain rather than pursuing fleeting pleasures. His thoughts on pleasure and virtue are developed in Nicomachean Ethics.
Aristotle believed that engaging wholeheartedly in work leads to fulfillment and excellence. He explores the link between satisfaction and productivity in Nicomachean Ethics.
This quote reflects Aristotle’s belief in critical thinking, where considering diverse viewpoints fosters wisdom. See more in Metaphysics, where he explores open-mindedness in intellectual inquiry.
Aristotle identified happiness as the ultimate goal of human life, achieved through virtuous living and fulfillment of one’s potential. He elaborates on this idea in Nicomachean Ethics.
Aristotle’s appreciation for nature reflects his curiosity about the world and his belief in the interconnectedness of all life. Physics offers a deeper dive into his views on natural wonders.
This quote underscores Aristotle’s view that intellectual vitality is central to a purposeful life. Learn more in Metaphysics, where he discusses the nature of the mind and spirit.
Aristotle argued that true friendships require selectivity and genuine mutual appreciation. Nicomachean Ethics contains a full discussion of Aristotle’s views on different types of friendship.
Aristotle saw humans as inherently social beings, needing community for a balanced life. His thoughts on society and solitude can be explored in Politics.
Aristotle admired resilience and grace under pressure, seeing it as a hallmark of virtue. Find his views on character in Nicomachean Ethics.
This quote reflects Aristotle’s belief in earning respect through moral integrity. His discussions on dignity are found in Nicomachean Ethics.
True friendship, Aristotle believed, develops gradually and requires time and trust. His exploration of friendship is detailed in Nicomachean Ethics.
This statement on synergy applies to both philosophy and science. Aristotle expands on this concept in Metaphysics.
Aristotle saw hope as an active pursuit, akin to a vision for the future. His reflections on hope can be found in Rhetoric.
Aristotle recognised the value of learning from others before leading. His thoughts on leadership are embedded in his works on ethics and politics.
Aristotle placed great value on education, seeing it as a transformative force that breathes life and understanding into individuals. His perspectives on education and its profound impact on the human soul are further explored in Politics.
Aristotle held that virtue includes a commitment to truth above public opinion, as integrity is key to character. He discusses the nature of truth and its relationship to character in Nicomachean Ethics.
Aristotle viewed law as an objective framework meant to guide society with logic rather than emotion, emphasizing justice and rationality over personal biases. He discusses the importance of law, reason, and justice in building a well-ordered society in Politics.
This quote reflects Aristotle’s approach to logic and rhetoric, highlighting that ideas should be believable and persuasive, even if they seem improbable. He addresses the value of coherence and plausibility in effective arguments in Rhetoric, a treatise on persuasive speech and writing.